Weltics
When I was in college I walked up a green hill to Jageshwar with a guide, M. You climb through the trees, you pass the last line of them, and then the ground just ends and the Himalayas are there. Nobody announces them. One moment you're in a forest and the next you're in a different world, and the forest was inside it all along.
I've been thinking about that walk because I'm trying to build a website that works like it. I call it my webwelt. It's a house with floors and rooms and an archive out back. It isn't anywhere close to that hill yet. But I think it points the right way, and I want to say why.
Anyways.
The web was designed as a library. A page is a document, and a URL is its shelf mark. That was a sensible design for the conditions of 1990, when the hard problem was getting a physics paper from Geneva to Illinois. The page sits at its address and waits for you. Thirty-five years later we still build that way, even when what we're making is less like a document and more like a place.
Those conditions have changed. AI can compose a world on the spot, for this visitor, from what the world is made of. A room doesn't need to be stored anywhere to be visited. It needs ingredients, relations and someone walking in.
So here's what I'd like to propose. Swap one word in Wittgenstein:
The world is all that is the cache.
Okay, that's a terrible joke. But it carries the idea. A web page is a fixed thing in a fixed place. A world in the new sense is assembled when needed, out of parts that live elsewhere, and it dissolves when you leave. I want to call these empty worlds, and I mean empty the way Nagarjuna meant it. Shunyata isn't nothingness. It's the absence of a thing's own fixed nature. An empty world has no address of its own. It's made entirely of its relations: what it quotes, who it lets in, where its doors lead.
Some of these worlds I'll control. Some I'll share with others, and some belong to others entirely. Many will be outside my ken altogether. Moving between them should feel like that last line of trees, not like clicking a link and waiting.
None of this is new, and I'm glad it isn't. Jakob von Uexküll gave us the umwelt in 1934, the world as each creature lives it, the tick's world of butyric acid and warmth. Nelson Goodman wrote Ways of Worldmaking in 1978 and argued that we make worlds out of other worlds, by composing, weighting, deleting and reordering. LambdaMOO had nested rooms built by its own inhabitants in 1990. Second Life had land you could own, and Croquet had portals you could walk through from one world into another. The Puranas did it with more style than any of them. Vishnu dreams the universe, and inside the dream a sage wanders into Vishnu's mouth and finds another universe there.
What's new is the AI twist. Worlds used to be authored in advance, at great cost, by people with budgets. Now they can be made on the fly, cheaply, by anyone who can describe what they want. That changes what a website is for.
I'd like to name the study of this weltics. For a while now I've been writing Bhumics, the study of terrestriality. Bhumics refuses the scientist's view from nowhere and takes the earthworm's view instead, from inside the soil, embedded and partial. Weltics is the part of Bhumics that deals with making and modeling worlds.
I was tempted to call weltics a counterpart of Bhumics, the formal mirror to the earthy original. Scratch that. A counterpart needs someone standing outside both, comparing the world with its model from a god's-eye seat. There is no such seat. The weltist makes worlds from inside Bhumi, with dirt under her nails, the way a weaverbird builds a nest from the tree it hangs in. Worldmaking is one more thing earthlings do.
The weltist is very much in Bhumi.
In my house this gets a little Escher-like. Weltics has a floor of its own, right above Street Metaphysics, but its stair goes up from inside Bhumics. Formetry, my old label for formal inquiry into mind and mathematics, becomes a suite of rooms on this floor, the ones with the most equations on the walls. Yes, I'm aware that coining a field in a framing note, and then building it a staircase, is the sort of thing people mock. Go ahead.
So far I've talked as if weltics had two faces. One is about worlds as such, Uexküll's tick and Goodman's versions, human worlds, animal worlds, maybe the world of a single cell. The other is about worlds as models, where AI's world models, cognitive science's mental models and the logician's theory of models all sit at one table. Both are fine. Both can also stay on paper forever, and that bothers me.
Models aren't only formal. Architects build models out of balsa and glue. Engineers build them out of steel. A weltics that stops at the formal model is still looking at the world from the god's-eye seat I just threw out.
To know is to make.
That isn't my line. Vico said verum ipsum factum in 1710, the true is the made, and Feynman left "What I cannot create, I do not understand" on his blackboard. I'm happy to inherit it. What I want to add is a third face of weltics, which I'll call realization. English got lucky with that word, since to realize means both to understand and to make real.
Heidegger helps here, much as it pains me to say so. A hammer that works disappears into the hammering. It only shows up as an object when it breaks. The architect's model sits on the table to be looked at. The building disappears into the living. My test for when a world has become real is that it can fail, and the earth is grading it.
The Indian temple got there first. Laid out on the vastu purusha mandala, it's a model of the cosmos that you walk into, live with and repair. Robots are the modern case and the sharpest one. A robot carries a world model around and gets corrected by stairs, floors and cats. It's a theory with legs.
Worlds, models, realizations. My gut says the third is where weltics will either prove itself or embarrass me.
I need one word for all of it, the composing, the making and the living-in. Heidegger, again, has it. Die Welt weltet, the world worlds. He also wrote an essay called "Building Dwelling Thinking", where building already is a way of dwelling and both are ways of thinking. So weltics is the study of worlding, and the weltist is anyone who worlds on purpose. That includes the architect, the robot builder, the novelist, the farmer laying out a field and, on a good day, me.
Weltics needs languages to reason in, and they come at different levels, the way computing has assembly language at the bottom and abstractions above it. In computing, though, the ladder doesn't start at assembly. It stands on hardware, silicon and copper and heat, and every abstraction eventually has to run there. Weltics is the same, so I see five rungs, and the bottom one is where realization lives.
- Making. The languages that turn form into matter: architectural drawings, CAD files and the instructions a milling machine follows, the control code of a robot, the shilpa shastras that told temple builders how a cosmos becomes stone. This rung talks back. Whatever is said on the rungs above has to come down here eventually, and the earth gets the last word.
- Protocols. Blygger sits here, close to assembly language. It can't give you space or rendering. What it does give you is the bookkeeping of worlds. An origin is a territory you control. A transclusion lets one world appear inside another with a record of where it came from. A fork lets someone take a world and make their own. Stubs and mentions are traffic between worlds, and a pin holds a world steady.
- World descriptions. A language for saying what a world is made of and how its parts go together. My 3D pattern language for little houses and streets is a crude first try. This is the rung most often skipped.
- World models. The AI sense of the term: systems that simulate a world and let you act in it.
- Empty reasoning. Reasoning about worlds themselves: which ones to make, which to live in, how they should relate. This is where I'd like to spend my time, and it's the least developed.
My gut says rung 2 is where the real work is, rung 4 is where the real arguments are, and rung 0 is where we find out who was right. Empty reasoning that never comes down to making is just daydreaming with better vocabulary.
I don't know whether the web will become a world of worlds or just a smarter library. I do know which one I'd rather live in. Which would you?
Rooms on this floor
Room on this floor: Weltist
Stair down: Bhumics